British Traditions Under Fire: 19 Practices That Are Being Questioned

Pete Law

Whether it’s afternoon tea or the pomp and ceremony of the royal family, certain customs have shaped British culture. However, as times change, so do attitudes and many long-standing practices are now being questioned. Let’s explore 19 British traditions that are currently under the spotlight.

The Future of Afternoon Tea

Photo Credit: Monkey Business Images/Shutterstock

“Afternoon tea was introduced in England by Anna, the seventh Duchess of Bedford, in the year 1840,” according to Historic UK, so some might argue it’s about time it goes out of fashion. Afternoon tea, with its delicate sandwiches, scones, and clotted cream, is a quintessentially British experience. However, fewer people are taking the time to indulge in this leisurely meal.

Changing Attitudes Towards the Royal Family

Photo Credit: Lorna Roberts/Shutterstock

The British monarchy has been a symbol of continuity and tradition for centuries, but in recent years, the role of the royal family has come under scrutiny. Questions about their relevance, the cost of maintaining the monarchy, and the behaviour of certain members have led some to argue that it’s time for a change.

Guy Fawkes Night

Photo Credit: SoulandCo/Shutterstock

Every 5th of November, Brits gather to celebrate Guy Fawkes Night with bonfires and fireworks. Yet this tradition, which commemorates the failed Gunpowder Plot of 1605, is increasingly being questioned. Some argue that it’s inappropriate to celebrate an event that is rooted in religious persecution and violence.

The Debate Over Remembrance Day

Photo Credit: Jesus Salas Dual/Shutterstock

Remembrance Day, held on the 11th of November, honours those who have died in military service. While this solemn tradition is widely respected, there is an ongoing debate about its relevance in a world where few have direct connections to the World Wars. Additionally, some younger people feel disconnected from the tradition.

Future of Fox Hunting

Photo Credit: Jason Mintzer/Shutterstock

Fox hunting has long been a contentious issue in Britain. Despite being banned in 2004, the practice persists in some areas under the guise of trail hunting, where hounds follow an artificial scent. Animal rights activists argue that the tradition is cruel and outdated, while supporters claim it is a vital part of rural life and pest control.

Changing Perspectives on Pub Culture

Photo Credit: charmedlightph/Shutterstock

The British pub has long been a social hub, a place where people come together to relax and unwind. Nevertheless, with changing drinking habits, the rise of health consciousness, and the closure of many local pubs, things are now slightly different. Some question whether the pub will remain a central part of British life.

Role of the House of Lords

Photo Credit: Tomas Marek/Shutterstock

Thanks to its unelected status and the appointment of life peers, the House of Lords has sparked debate about its legitimacy in a modern democracy. Critics argue that it’s an outdated institution that should be reformed or replaced with an elected body.

Controversy of British Public Schools

Photo Credit: BearFotos/Shutterstock

Like Eton and Harrow, British public schools are known for their history, tradition, and role in educating the nation’s elite. However, these institutions are increasingly criticised for perpetuating social inequality and maintaining a privileged class. Some argue that such schools undermine the principle of equal opportunity.

Evolution of British Manners

Photo Credit: N U S A R A/Shutterstock

Often stereotyped as exceptionally polite, British people emphasise manners and etiquette. However, as society becomes more diverse and informal, traditional British manners are being questioned. Some view them as outdated or even insincere, while others believe they are an important part of social cohesion.

Fate of Traditional British Cuisine

Photo Credit: Monkey Business Images/Shutterstock

Once mocked for its blandness, British cuisine has undergone a renaissance in recent years. However, some traditional dishes, like jellied eels and black pudding, are falling out of favour as people embrace more international and health-conscious diets. There is a growing concern that these culinary traditions could be lost.

Christmas Pantomime Tradition

Photo Credit: Elena Rostunova/Shutterstock

Full of slapstick humour, cross-dressing characters, and audience participation, Christmas pantomimes are a beloved UK tradition. Yet, some elements of pantomime—such as the portrayal of gender roles and the use of outdated stereotypes—are being criticised. In an era of increasing awareness about representation and inclusivity, there is a call to modernise pantomimes.

Future of the BBC Licence Fee

Photo Credit: Nigel J. Harris/Shutterstock

The BBC is a cornerstone of British culture, known for its high-quality programming and public service broadcasting. However, the licence fee, which funds the BBC, is increasingly controversial, as some argue that it is an outdated model in the age of streaming services.

Relevance of the British Empire Legacy

Photo Credit: jan kranendonk/Shutterstock

Once spanning the globe, the British Empire and its legacy are still felt today. This legacy is increasingly being questioned, with debates over how Britain’s colonial past should be remembered and taught. Some argue that the focus should be on the Empire’s achievements and benefits, while others believe that the darker aspects must be acknowledged.

Ceremony of Changing the Guard

Photo Credit: Shutterstock

The Changing of the Guard at Buckingham Palace is one of the most iconic British traditions, attracting tourists from around the world. Critics, however, argue that it is a costly and unnecessary spectacle that reinforces outdated ideas about the monarchy and the military.

The Debate Over the Countryside Alliance

Photo Credit: Elzbieta-Sekowska/Shutterstock

The Countryside Alliance is an organisation that advocates for rural communities and traditional country pursuits, such as hunting, shooting, and fishing. But, it has caused debate over animal welfare, environmental sustainability, and social inclusivity issues. Critics argue that the Countryside Alliance promotes practices that are harmful and out of step with modern values.

Controversy Around St George’s Day

Photo Credit: Andrew E Gardner/Shutterstock

St George’s Day, celebrated on 23rd April, is England’s national day. However, it’s not widely observed, and some people wonder about its relevance and the way it is celebrated. Some people argue that St George’s Day should be a public holiday, with more emphasis on English culture and history.

The Role of the Church of England

Photo Credit: Boris Stroujko/Shutterstock

The Church of England has been an established church in England for centuries, with the monarch as its Supreme Governor. However, its role in an increasingly secular society is also being questioned. The debate touches on issues of tradition, identity, and social change.

Future of the British Seaside Holiday

Photo Credit: Sergey Novikov/Shutterstock

With its piers, amusement arcades, and fish and chips, the British seaside holiday is a nostalgic tradition for many. However, changing holiday habits and the rise of budget airlines have led to a decline in the popularity of British seaside resorts. The future of the British seaside holiday remains uncertain as it faces the challenge of adapting to modern tastes.

Relevance of the British Constitution

Photo Credit: Shutterstock

Lastly, Britain’s constitution is an unwritten collection of laws, conventions, and principles that have evolved over centuries. Supporters believe that its flexibility is a strength, allowing it to adapt to changing circumstances. Butl, the debate over whether Britain should adopt a written constitution continues to be a topic of discussion.